Monday, 21 August 2006

  • Potty-Training......is overrated

    My son seems reasonably intelligent. I mean at 2 ½ he counts to 10, and counts backwards like this: 10, 7, 4, 2, 1, always followed by BLASTOFF! He can sing most of the alphabet song. He is putting concepts about God and family connections together in the most amazing ways. (I realized the other day though, after hearing him say loudly and in a demanding tone of voice “God, stop raining!!”, that his concept of God may need a bit of help...)

     

    But, alas, he will not be potty-trained.

    Help.

    We have tried all the methods I’ve ever heard of including (but not limited to) wearing shorts, pull-ups, nothing/nada (no more details on this method).

     

    Not to say he fits into any category I’ve ever heard of. He wakes up dry and has for months. He LIKES going in the potty. He proclaims proudly when he does go in the potty that “big boys DON’T poop in their shorts.”

    So what’s the issue you ask?

    Life is just way, way too interesting to take time out for potty breaks.

    Sigh.

    I prayed the other day that I would never offer theories to other moms about what works for potty training. I even prayed that I wouldn’t ask other moms whether their children are trained.

    Tonight while eating dinner with friends I asked my friend, “is your daughter trained?”, and promptly apologized. I should be ashamed to admit that I was glad when she overrode my apology and admitted her daughter isn’t trained either.

    I wonder why it’s such a big deal to us? 

Comments (14)

  • bpchecker
    dear momma, he is only 2 1/2!!!! note: easy to say for a non-momma, eh?? blessings!
  • weswife
    Carolyn - yours is sitting on my counter waiting for an address........ maybe i can get it sent off today! :) I had no idea you had a site! I'll see you this week end hopefully. Love to you all - ginny
  • dlm4christ
    Sounds interesting!!! :) I was older than that. Mom about gave up on me but I'm glad she didn't! :) I guess I was a little thick skulled. Have a great week! DLM
  • jkamfamily
    I felt the same way with my first one and vowed I would never even try until way old. But this one was so different.  No matter how hard I tried to put her off she kept wanting too. So, I decided each child is unique in other ways,why do we try to force the same potty training methods on each one. But I can't take any credit, she literally did it herself. Hope it goes good soon!! Good to hear from you too. (with Alexis, when she decided it was time it took 2 weeks to be totally trained! after weeks of agony trying to MAKE her do it)
  • justcallmeM

    Have lots of advice to give.... ha ha ha!!! :) Hang in there!!

  • admin2b

    first day in school..come home and try to figure out who u are. yup, got it now. i am going to say that Alex's comment "big boys don't poop in pants is not true.

    sorry, but i feel a bit that way tonight. sure it will get easier as time goes on. tell Jason hello. RUDY

  • lifethots
    I'm smiling!  AND REMEMBERING!!  All I can say (after 5 kiddo's) is that somehow there is or can be a disconnection between the mind/will/(and emotions too if you please), and the "mechanism".  And it simply needs TIME to "mature"!   Time--the master teacher for the trained and the untrained!  We had both kinds-- the easy and the extremely difficult!  Methods were the same!  This too shall pass!  My sympathies!
  • qualitybarns
    Hi Carolyn!!! Didn't know you had a site! :) Look forward to hearing from you and your little family! Love, Kim
  • justcallmeM

    About the book... this is only the umpteenth time I've read it. Haven't read any others of hers. I think I got it at a bookstore in Fernandina. I think at the time I was just impressed with how old it was! E.D.E.N. Southworth is another favorite old author. Have you read any of her books? Highly recommend Ishmael or In the Depths and the sequel Self-Made or Out of the Depths. Don't you just love alternate titles? :)

  • vettechstudent
    Carolyn!  How awesome to find you have a site.  But the bad thing is, now you can check up on me.  At least we can kind of keep in touch with what is going on in our lives.  Janel M.
  • Lockhart2
    I dont know you from adam....but i just happened on your site...lets just say im not an expert by no means,i have no children but i have been a nanny for 12 years, and i have potty trained some children, what i have found that works ( most times they have to be ready) is getting them to read a book, watch a video, to get their mind off of it, when you first start off ,because when they do it their mind will come back to it, and they will be like "Momma i did it" one thing i offered was everytime they went they got a treat, usually a piece of candy. and it worked wonders...I dont know if it will work in your case but i thot i would tell you anyways...Marlene
  • thehershbergers
    dont know who you are, but i sure can sympithise with you on your potty training adventure!!!!!!!!!i have a 2 1/2 yr. old {almost}and very smart does alot of the things you listed ,but refuses to take a break  away from toys to go to the potty!!!!! i feel your pain cause alot of his little friends in church are trained ,but oh well they will get it some day.i will be praying for you as you keep trying.---annie
  • teacuplover
    Hi! Just found your site!! Didn't realize you had one!!  Potty training...boys...yes..3 of them...each in their own timing...Mario trained with candy....he still loves his sweets....I don't think that worked with Tony or Matthew... I just waited till they were ready...3 or 4 I think..!!Anyways ...nice seeing you have a site!!
  • ma_an_pa
    Hi! Just "happened" upon your site recently. May you be encouraged with the fact that you are not the only one in the world who has an untrained 2 1/2 year old son!! Oh- what shall we do?
  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

Who recommended?